Once Upon a Time in Russia…..

It was a cold December Saturday afternoon, and I was hunting around for a substantial read. I wanted to read something in-depth, something fulfilling with layered narrative but could not find the right book. I was reaching for a Austen but then changed my mind and tried reading Selected Letters by Lady Mary Wortley Montagu and though this was a book I had been really looking forward to, it was not working for me. So I was sitting blankly and gazing at my Black Penguin Classics shelf and for no reason I suddenly picked up and started re-reading Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy. The idea was that it will not work for me either and I can probably stop in a while. But somehow I kept turning page after page and yes, there were days when I would not pick it up because I needed time to process it all. But every time I went back to it, I was again turning page after page!

The tale is too well known for me to add anything new. But for those may not have read it, here is brief synopsis. The story opens with chaos reigning supreme in the Oblonsky household; Dolly Oblonksy has discovered the affairs of her husband Stepan Oblonsky and is preparing to go back to her parent’s household. Stepan is apologetic but incapable of doing anything else and is greatly relieved when his sister Anna, married to Alexei Karenin, a senior and a powerful statesman to help mend the rift. Anna is a beautiful, graceful, intelligent and a glittering star in the St. Petersburg society, has traveled to Moscow in the company of Countess Vronskaya, a rich old lady, whose son Count Alexei Vronsky, a friend of Stepan Oblonksy is at the station to receive his mother and meets Stepan and Anna, the latter for the first time. Count Vronksy is a cavalry officer and the star of the Moscow society who many think will go far. He is currently a favorite in the Shcherbatskaya household, especially with the youngest daughter Kitty who is also Dolly Oblonksy’s sister and their mother. It is hoped that Count Vronksy will make a proposal to Kitty who believes herself to be in love with him and turns down the proposal of Konstantin “Kostya” Levin, an old friend of Stepan Oblonsky and a landowner and farmer and a radical thinker. Anna in the meanwhile is able to convince Dolly to stay on and give Stepan a chance and having restored the equilibrium of the household attends a fashionable ball where she meets Count Vronsky again which leads to a tumultuous results.

I had read Anna Karenina the summer before I started college. I was all of 17 and very sure of everything and a mistress in understanding of one and all. I read the book and all I remember at the end of it was wondering why is it considered such a literary masterpiece? I did not like Anna and could not find sufficient reasons to dislike her husband and was irritated by Levin. This was one book I was not going back to and I stuck to that resolution for over 20 years, until the December afternoon. I still do not like Anna, I get that she in a loveless marriage but I did not and still do not understand why she married Karenina in the first place. And while he was not the love of her life, he was still a good husband, a good provider and I could find no reason to dislike him. But now I am less judgmental, I can understand her anguish and insecurities about Vronksy , though I am still not fully reconciled with her act of vengeance. But what this re-reading brought me was the understanding that this novel is so much more than Anna and there are so many complex layers to this narrative and an very immersive but non romanticized but gentle telling of the the then Russian society and state.

I loved the story of Kitty and Levin and felt sad for Dolly. I rejoiced in the humor of Prince  Shcherbatskaya and found much to appreciate in the nuanced characters of the secondary actors like Varvara Andreevna, who becomes Kitty’s friend at the German Spa and Agafya Mikhailovna, Levin’s former nurse. I was caught up in their tales and felt myself restlessly turning the page to know what finally happens to Varvara at the mushroom picking. Most of all I loved the rich socio-politico narrative of Russia that is presented. There are no high flown virtues attributed the newly freed serfs; they like every human being are a mix of good and bad, resistant to new changes but opening their homes and hearts. The same could be said about the noblemen, especially the new ones growing up in the light of European enlightenment, who want to bring modern education and farming to their former serfs, thinking of these actions as a moral obligation on their part, without wholly understanding their people or their customs. There are no black villains or white heroes; just people in grey who are trying to do their best per their understanding or even despite their understanding. This is especially evident in the way Tolstoy describes Anna’s downward spiral and final breakdown. While I still did not like her, I found sympathy for the way a charming and confident woman devolved into despair and irrationality. This kind of narrative is the testimony of the brilliance of Tolstoy; you don’t like her but you cannot help feeling sad about her. And woven into all of this is the gentle telling of some basic human values – of love, of camaraderie, of human happiness and perhaps its ephemeral constantly changing nature and finally that happiness cannot really be built on grounds made of other’s sufferings.

I now want to re-read War and Peace again; I had loved it everytime I read it and now feel will do so even more!

13 thoughts on “Once Upon a Time in Russia…..

  1. I’ve only read this book once, years ago, but I remember I also disliked Anna and was more interested in Kitty and Levin. I would like to read it again one day, and maybe try a different translation next time.

    1. Anna despite all her charm and intelligence just does not become likeable. Kitty and Levin narrative I agree is far more appealing and I think that was a motif that Tolstoy actually deployed to display the stark contrast. Definitely recommend a second visit sometime!

  2. a masterly review! i read this when young also and it’s definitely time to do it again… readers, especially myself, get stuck in grooves and need a joggle sometimes to reset to default status, lol…

    1. You always lift my spirits up! Thank You for the kind words! I think sometimes a re-read is good exactly for the reason you mention – to reset the default button. It’s a good way to understand how much we have changed or not!

  3. Sometimes a re-read is just what you need! I read this relatively recently, and at my age had considerably less tolerance for the selfishness of the lovers than I might have when I was younger. And although Karenin has issues, I don’t think he deserves the treatment he gets. Putting that aside, it’s a wonderful novel and I hope you *do* re-read War and Peace!!

    1. The selfishness of the lovers is certainly the major theme of the book and I did not like either of them. But I do understand how after having left everything behind, Anna would become obsessed with Vronsky. But again no excuses, I agree with you completely on Karenin; I think he is not really a bad man and got the raw end of the stick! I do want to read War and Peace again but like you said, need a good translation.

  4. Ha, ha! How could you pick up a Tolstoy novel and think you could just put it down again. 😉 Thanks so much for the excellent review which allowed me to reconnect with all the characters and reminded me that I really want to read it again soon. I love everything Tolstoy!

    1. Because I did not like it the first time. But I should have known better because I love War and Peace. 🙂 Thank You for your kind words! I totally understand your love for Tolstoy

  5. Isn’t it amazing how rereading something when older turns it into a whole new story and a completely different experience? I reread Jane Austen’s books regularly and always discover something new. Love it!

    1. I always do a annual homage to at least one JA novel every year and you are so right, each re-read opens up ideas that we did not notice before. Re-reading especially after a prolonged time period, like you said is like reading a whole new story!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s